The Art of Evaluation
Toastmasters Evaluation Tips for Effective Feedback. In a Toastmasters club, we have prepared speeches, impromptu speeches and prepared speech evaluation segments. As a Toastmaster, giving a speech evaluation is ultimately inevitable and gives us very important lessons. Do you agree, only when we know how to evaluate our own speeches and others. Delivering an evaluation is an excellent way to practice and demonstrate your speaking skills. Remember these five points: 1. Before the speech, review the evaluation guidelines for that particular project and approach the speaker to discuss the objectives for their speech.
Podcast: Play in new window Download. A clean slate with speed and power. Maybe now I can fill out evaluations on my computer and send them back to people? There are the 10 bazillion miles of black cablesЕ. A new computer opens up new opportunities for me. Moving Toastmasters meetings online opens up new opportunities for all of us, such as evaluating online speeches.
Are you ready to improve your public speaking and leadership skills? Then you are ready for Toastmasters. Evaluations are the key component of Toastmasters. You can get public speaking training in a lot of places Ч most of them for a lot more money Ч but getting immediate feedback is where real growth is made.
I never could. It was allergic to Adobe and hated fillable PDFs. I silk flower bouquets how to make prefer another program that I used instead Ч Foxit Ч but I know most people use Adobe.
Zoom has a page about how to share documents Ч the link is in the show notes. This does mean that we need to adjust our presentations accordingly. Do you know how movement translates on the screen? I scared my fellow Toastmasters last week when I ranted Ч er- gave a speech Ч and leaned into the camera as a way to indicate my irritation with my computer cables Ч the bazillion miles of black cable that I have to unwrap from each other and try to determine where they go in the back of my new computer.
I know I scared one of them Ч he mentioned it in chat! I never thought that evaluating online speeches how does the electoral college elect a president be scary!
Therefore, consider what this new platform requires in your performance. Also, pay attention to how you can share your screen if you have slides.
We have one member who prepares a slide deck for almost every one of her speech projects Ч but consistently has issues sharing her screen. Get out of your chair for your presentations. Make sure that the camera angle also captures your face and not a backlit silhouette does. But remember, your evaluator might be looking at you for the very first time for evaluating online speeches. Again, I learn more from my evaluation -giving than giving speeches or getting evaluations!
When I have the right evaluation form in front of me to evaluate you, it helps me give you a good evaluation Ч but also to help me learn what I can do too! In the past, that was good enough for me to give to a speaker. Chicken scratches and all Ч you got the whole of my in-the-moment impressions of your speech and I handed it to you at the end of the evaluation with a handshake or at the end of the meeting.
Will we still shake hands in Toastmasters when we meet again in person? And before you make fun of me for wanting a copy of it Ч please know that I keep these what is mobile web app. I still have my first, second, third Competent Communicator manuals in a box in my basement.
Some of those evaluators are gone now. Others live across the country. There are two obvious options. First, I print out the evaluation at my home, write on it, and then mail the physical copy to the speaker. Evaluating online speeches with off-line technology? I know one Toastmaster who writes down notes, takes a picture of them, and then messages the pic over. I have to question the readability.
Honestly, I can barely read the texts I get Ч pictures with words? I can barely read the memes my kids send to me. This option may work for many people. The other obvious option is to fill in the PDF and send it to the speaker.
Should I try to scan it with my original notes and email it or should I retype my notes on the PDF form? Should I send it through the meeting platform or email? These are all good questions. Some should be addressed by the club Ч it would be good if there were a club standard and everyone adhered to it. It will give you a page about your club member Ч their public how to resize photos on vista, including an email address.
We have an option to ask people for feedback on Pathways. We have an option to send our evaluations through the My Feedback tab if both the speaker and the evaluator are in the same club AND you are both logged into Pathways in the same club.
Part of me approves of this Ч less opportunity for spam, less useless messaging. On the Base Camp page, how to store einstein bagels for a name of the person you want to send your filled-out evaluation to, and select them from the dropdown list. That opens up their profile screen. You can attach the PDF or image file there and send it directly to the speaker.
You can also award badges, which are like electronic stickers or virtual pats on the back. This podcast is long enough! Toastmasters podcast is a production of Toastmasters District Skip to content.
How to Be an Enriching, Encouraging and Effective Evaluator
Evaluate the Speech, not the Speaker As a project evaluator you should be evaluating the speakerТs speech crafting, the speech structure, speech value, speech logic, project objectives and his delivery. You do not want to evaluate based on your feelings of the speaker. DonТt like the speaker? SPEECH EVALUATION iii PREFACE I have often heard Toastmasters in South Australia (new and experienced) express that they do not volunteer to evaluate other speakers as they lack confidence in their ability to evaluate well, and many do not enjoy the. May 20, †Ј From the speech project on Base Camp. YouТll see a drop-down menu at the bottom of the screen Ц Your Evaluation is one of the choices. You may download it and send it to your evaluator. This is a fillable PDF, so if they have the option, they can fill it out and email it to you.
Have you ever wondered how to give great evaluation speeches? Here are some Toastmasters evaluation tips to help you guide others in their public speaking journey. In a Toastmasters club, we have prepared speeches, impromptu speeches and prepared speech evaluation segments. As a Toastmaster, giving a speech evaluation is ultimately inevitable and gives us very important lessons.
Do you agree, only when we know how to evaluate our own speeches and others, we can identify which areas we can improve on? Be it delivery, speech content, audience engagement and etc. Thus, evaluation in Toastmasters is in fact sharping our:. From speech evaluations, we can also apply the skills in our work and life too, e. In short, speech evaluation is not only adding values to the speakers, it also grooms us in many ways. So, we must be helpful and try our very best to extend help to the speaker.
All the key evaluation points must serve the purpose to help the speaker and ADD VALUE ; highlight what they have done well and point out what they can do better. Within the time limit of 3 and a half minutes, we need to be precise and specific on our evaluation, so that we can maximize the value we are adding to the speaker. Guarantee it will be useful for new evaluators. This is a very common easy-to-apply technique which start with positive points Praises , followed by negative points Areas for Improvement and closed with positive points Praises again.
Reason behind this technique is, we start with positive feedback to build a friendly relationship with the person. Then we suggest some ideas on how the speaker can improve some people might perceive it as criticism. So, the first part not only highlights the excellent skills which the speaker can continue applying, it also serves as cushion for the recommendation for improvement.
Lastly close with a positive note to give hope and encouragement to the speaker. Showing the speaker an example of your feedback can help the speaker to understand you and absorb the feedback easier. Basically, your evaluation will be using the story as an analogy sound like telling a story with Sandwich technique inside. In conclusion, I would like to leave this note to you. Evaluation is not only helping the speaker but ourselves too. Learn from one another and be fantastic speakers together.
All the best! Hope this sharing helps you in your speech evaluation. Thank you for reading and feel free to share this with your friends. Although you may be seasoned enough to step into the role of an evaluator, there are times the pressure still gets to us.
Your email address will not be published. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Looking back on my journey, I decided to start this website for new speakers to learn from my mistakes, triumphs and perspectives. All rights reserved. Public Speaking Elements. Toastmasters Evaluation Tips for Effective Feedback In a Toastmasters club, we have prepared speeches, impromptu speeches and prepared speech evaluation segments.
Be Specific Within the time limit of 3 and a half minutes, we need to be precise and specific on our evaluation, so that we can maximize the value we are adding to the speaker. Sandwich Feedback Technique This is a very common easy-to-apply technique which start with positive points Praises , followed by negative points Areas for Improvement and closed with positive points Praises again. Example shortened version : Garen, thank you very much for your informative speech. I like your animated delivery and entertaining content.
I look forward to your next speech. Pay attention to your choice of words when giving negative feedback. Remember to start with praises, then highlight areas of improvement, and close your evaluation with positive note. For example, ABC A wesome, can do B etter, C hallenge A wesome: put spotlight on what the speaker has done well can do B etter: share how the speaker can do better C hallenge: Other than what can be done better, challenge the speaker to go to next level.
Conclude with ABC again. Storytelling Technique This technique is my very own idea and I think it works very well too. He has included some fun things he has gone through and mishaps happened along the journey.
Applying the Storytelling Technique After listening to your story, I feel like I was with you when you hiked. Your speech is just like your hiking experience. What you have done well to reach the peak are 1 , 2 , 3. May I recommend you how you can make your hiking journey even more interesting?
Hope you can apply these tips into your next speech and I believe you can conquer Mount Everest in no time. This technique breaks the classic structure a little and gives the audience a fresh listening experience. Humour and entertaining elements can be easily added in as well. Still, we shall not forget to be helpful, specific, and purposeful.
The above are some techniques we can apply when giving a speech evaluation. Toastmasters Evaluation Tips 3: Areas of Feedback You might ask what are the areas we can give our feedback on? Some points you may want to observe will be: Message every speech MUST have a message; can you identify the message of the speech? Effectiveness, Reception? Structure the flow and logic are smooth or can be better? Organization , support material speech development?
Any call to action? Is message being emphasized again? Any grammatical error or pronunciation mistakes can be corrected? Choice of words? Emotion is the emotion element in place?
Heart Breaking? Area 2: Visual Body Language hand gestures, facial expression, etc Stage Positioning left to right in chronological sequence, standing still for one point, any unnecessary movement? Eye Contact sufficient eye contact? Stage Presence Is the speaker appearing confident and exhibiting the right aura on stage? Speaking Area? Appearance Appropriate attire? Visibility on stage Ч not blocked by podium or white board Visual Aids any visual aid such as PowerPoint, whiteboard or props can enhance the delivery?
Any inappropriate visual aid the speaker can omit? Soft and loud appropriately? Vocal Variety Monotonous? Using high and low tones appropriately to capture attention? Pacing Faster amid excitement, slower to project emotion Dialogue impersonation, change of voice during dialogue? Small Activity involve audience to do certain actions, etc. Conclusion: Toastmasters Evaluation Tips I believe these would be sufficient for you to come out with useful feedback for the speaker.
If you have any comment or need any clarification, please feel free to drop your comments. Summary Begin your evaluations with the right mindset to help the speaker.
Use the Sandwich method, examples and a story to structure your evaluation. Areas of feedback include content, delivery and vocal elements. Your Free Gift! June 18, at am. Leave a Reply Cancel reply Your email address will not be published. Behind The PostsЕ Hello! Show Me How! Share via.
Copy Link. Powered by Social Snap. Copy link. Copy Copied.